Mateo's Deli & Bagels
Mateo's signature Italian hero stacked with meats, cheeses and fresh veggies
Baldwin, NY · Since day one
Hablamos Español

Baldwin's Favorite Deli & Bagel Experience

Fresh bagels, stacked sandwiches, breakfast favorites, and friendly service served daily.

Call Now Order Delivery

Large Hero $13.99 · Small Hero $9.99

4.8 Rating· Loved by neighbors

Our Story

A neighborhood deli, made with heart.

Mateo's is a family-owned local business right here in Baldwin, rooted in our Christian faith. Every bagel is hand-rolled, every sandwich is stacked with care, and every customer is greeted like family. We've built our deli on three simple ideas: real ingredients, fresh preparation, and the kind of service that makes Baldwin feel like home.

From early-morning coffee runs to lunch-rush classics, we're here to feed your day — the right way.

4.8★
Google Rating
Daily
Fresh Baked
Family
Owned & Local
Mateo's Deli & Bagels storefront on Merrick Rd

Delivery

Get Mateo's delivered.

Craving bagels at home? Order through your favorite delivery app — we're live on all three.

DoorDash

Fast doorstep delivery

Order on DoorDash

Uber Eats

Track every step

Order on Uber Eats

Grubhub

Order with rewards

Order on Grubhub

Prefer to skip the fees? Call us directly and place your order for pickup.

Why Mateo's

Why customers love us

Freshly Made Daily

Bagels baked at sunrise and sandwiches built to order — never sitting.

Premium Ingredients

Quality meats, cheeses, and produce sourced with care.

Fast Friendly Service

In and out quick — without ever feeling rushed.

Neighborhood Favorite

Proudly serving Baldwin with smiles, one order at a time.

Visit Us

Come on in.

We're easy to find, easy to love. Stop by for a fresh bagel or call ahead for pickup.

Address
986 Merrick Rd
Baldwin, NY 11510
Hours
Mon–Sat · 6am – 6pm
Sun · 7am – 4pm
Get Directions Call Now

Hungry? Visit Mateo's today.

Fresh out the oven, stacked to order, and ready when you are.

Get Directions Call Now
Call Now